Monday, April 25, 2011

Memorandum against Fee-Hike submitted to Principal

IISJ Parents' Voice Team met IISJ Principal Mr. Syed Masood Ahmed on 25th April 2011 at his office and submitted the memorandum below along with parents' comments received  for our earlier post  "Parents appeal to the Principal".  .
  
The Principal allowed us to talk freely our concerns about fee hike and other issues of IISJ & assured us he will forward our suggestion to higher board for their review and consideration.


Below is the memorandum submitted to the Principal:
==========================================================

April 23, 2011

To     :       International Indian School Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

Attn. :       Mr. Syed Masood Ahmed        Cc : Consulate General, Jeddah
The Principal                              : Higher Board IISJ
                                                               
Sub :       IISJ Parents joint appeal to reconsider the fee hike.

Respected sir,

This has reference to your Circular # IIS/JED/PRL/2010-11 dated 22-March-2011 regarding academic and infrastructural development of Indian School and the unilateral decision to go for a considerable fee hike, which we, parents (organized under the www.iisjparents.blogspot.com) of International Indian School express our serious concern & anguish jointly and request you to reconsider the fee hike in view of our suggestions outlined below as follows:

Our concerns:
The first and foremost – the concerns of parents were not been taken care while implementing such a fee hike. 
a.    Absence of PTA:  We believe that as expatriate Indian parents in Jeddah, we are the part of the school, but never got a chance to know what are the gains and issues of the school. It is quite unfortunate that we, parents don’t have any voice in this community institution, and we feel that parents are treated merely as the fees payers.
b.    The school financial status is not published and been kept many years not transparent.  Since it is a public/ Community institution – there should be an elected body of the parents and the officials of the school.  This will enable the parents to get updated on the financial /educational / administrational status of school at any time.
c.    Our school is having surplus/ reserve amount in the past where the teachers were not paid reasonably. Now squeezing the parents by projecting this issue is not justifiable.  As a community School, it should be a no profit / no loss institution, whereas the school has accumulated a huge reserve of millions over the years.  The said amount has never been used for the improvement of school on a time bound schedule. Our IISJ has to be transformed a lot, to keep abreast with the standards of other CBSE schools in the region and in India. 
d.   School Transportation: The existing transportation facility does not meet the requirements comparing to the strength of our students. Our school buses are fully packed with more students than its capacity. But instead of improving the facility adding more buses in to the fleet, school authorities are on a privatization programme and the private (contract) transporter is using the same school for his service,  which raises enough doubts on the credibility of the decision.
e.   Lack of a body to evaluate the efficiency of the teachers has been noticed that there are a lot of teachers whom have to be retired long back/there are teachers not up to the standards still continuing. There should be a proper body to evaluate the efficiency of teachers/motivate and refresh them time to time. If it is due to non-availability of qualified and efficient teachers, the parents should be informed of it and the committee including parents should find ways to solve the issue. 
Refresher courses, run by highly qualified experts, at least once a year should be given to the teachers.
f.    Pvt. Tuition by Indian School Teachers:  A serious issue the parents are facing is the unscrupulous private tuitions conducted by the teachers of IISJ. The students in higher classes are compelled to go for private tuition, which has been brought to the attention of school authorities several times in the past, but no action has been taken yet.  Once the salaries of the teachers are increased the private tuition should be stopped.  The management committee of parents and teachers should monitor this.
g.   We understand that it is the wrong assessment that all parents are drawing a good salary and are able to bear this fee hike:  The parents should be given a platform to communicate their issues on a timely basis and a common PTA should convene every quarter of the year at least.

Other concerns of parents were attached herewith which we received through online via www.iisjparents.blogspot.com

Our suggestion(s):
1.   Before implementing any rise in the fees, a parent teachers meeting should be convened and the complaints of parents should be taken care of.
2.   Prepare a 5 years Master Plan for the infrastructural development of the school (including the increment of salary of sfaff) & implement it phase to phase in an appropriate manner.
3.   The said plan should be discussed and agreed at least for the first two years by the body – accordingly  take a decision to increase the fee.
4.   Instead of privatizing the transportation facilty, the school should be benefitted and more buses should be added to the fleet.
5.   The surplus fund, if any, should be invested to a scheme and the profit should be provided to the welfare of school teachers and staff.
6.   Implement double shift instead of buying expensive land inside city area and construct new buildings, that can avoid to squeeze  SR 70 millions from the poor parents

In view of the above concerns and suggestion, we kindly request you to freeze the current order of fees hike and implement the same in an amicable manner with the full support of the parents.  Let us work together for the success of our IISJ and our kids.

Best regards,

Signatories:
Sd/-
Siraj Kollam, Noushad Adoor, Nasar Chavakkad & Ashraf Unneen

6 comments:

  1. The Principal, Mr. Syed Masood Ahmed allowed us to talk freely about all our concern where his response was very upright and fairly innocent. His main concern was teachers’ remuneration which should be revised at any cost. Anyway, I’m sharing with you some of the points we raised verbally at his office and see his response.

    Q. Sir, why can’t we have transparency in financial status of the school?:
    A. It should be transparent and the last MC was considering this subject.

    Q. Do you think such a huge hike is required to resolve the teachers’ increment?
    A. The volume of fee increment was not calculated by me and it is from Accounts people….

    Q. Why not reinstating the MC and PTA?:
    A. See, I am not against it. There was PTA & MC in the past for this school. It can be formed again. Why not..

    Q. Poor parents ( low income group) are not considered while imposing such huge hike in fee. Is it not true?:
    A. It is not completely right. For those are poor, they can request us to consider for fee concession with valid reason. Even now many parents are getting fee concession if they are eligible for it due to sickness, handicapped, etc..

    Q. Can we implement 2 shift in the school like Pakistani School do?:
    A. CG and myself went to Saudi Authorities... until the Jeddah Governorate office for this subject, but they rejected our request, since it is a rule to stop the school by 3 pm.

    Q. You might be noticed that an email is floating around where uncomfortable pictures of KG children experienced in our school. What is the truth, is it proper to mark on children’s hands like this?:
    A. Surely Not. I have given instruction to the concerned staff not to repeat these mishaps.
    (to be continued)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Q. Transportation, especially for KG children now. Too much delay in dropping back home?:
    A. We are trying our level best to settle all issues. This morning, myself was on the street infront of KG to observe the problem we face there. Anyway, parking facility for 73 buses in front of this new bldg for KG is not at all an easy task. May be the municipality will interfere and will close the school if we didn’t comply with their rules. The delay in dropping back will be settled as soon as the new drivers acquainted with the new routes and system.

    Q. Sir, parents are suffering from the over burden of tuition for their children, especially for higher classes. What is your opinion about it?:
    A. See, it is a fashion now. Many of our parents are sending their children for tuition due to a bad norm prevailed in the society. Last year the school authority conducted special tuition & model exams for those who required . Apart from class room, if the students are ready to benefit from facilities provided by us, wouldn’t be required for further tuition outside.

    Q. In short, are you going to reconsider this fee hike.?:
    A. Your concern and suggestion will be forwarded to Higher Board for their review and consideration.
    (to be continued)

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Conclusion: It is a pleasure to talk to you, sir. There are many other concerns too. Kindly review them in our memorandum where the parents’ concerns and some of our suggestion are provided. Also, please pay attention to visit our blog frequently to be in touch with parents; especially this community school is not having PTA.
    Response: Sure, I will do and it is a pleasure to meet you all.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    In my opinion this fee hike is a planned scheme of some who are considering the public as less important. As long as we, the public, are less reactive to respond against this unscrupulous deed in an effective manner, the concerned authority will definitely move with their own agenda of fee hike. So more consistency is required in protest from the all side, especially from sincere politicians and brave parents.


    Ashraf Unneen
    Team Member of IISJ Parent’s Voice Delegation

    ReplyDelete
  5. Appreciate the effort of Mr. Ashraf Unneen and team in addressing the hot issues in IISJ.

    From the Q&A given here, it can be noticed that the team has done good home work before the visit.

    I am sure this meeting and its publishing in the blog will have a great impact.

    In the mean time let me appreciate the principal for his open approach, the way school is trying to solve the problems in KG section etc.

    Last week while I attended the parents meeting for class -9, the HM Mr. Noufal said that all the PT teachers are deployed in the KG section to streamline the issues there.

    I am optimistic about the future of IISJ.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The efforts and steps taken by Mr.Asharfa Unneen and his team will be a great mileage in the way of our fight against the unreasonable fee hike. This type of meeting of parents with Principal should continue until the climate to form a PTA and MC are attained.

    Congrats again for the leading steps...!

    ReplyDelete